|
Steeling Experiment Raw Data
Data
numbers in the table
is the number of the impact roller cycles with the resulting sharpness.
E.g. “ x5 = 250, x10 = 300 “ means after 5 impact cycles the edge
sharpness is 250 BESS, after 10 cycles 300 BESS, and so on.
All sharpened at 15 dps
|
SWIBO 5.8404.16 →
|
Test
#1
|
Steeling
|
Test
#2
|
Steeling
|
|
Initial Sharpness
|
134
|
|
116
|
|
|
SHARPNESS
|
x5=359
x10=384
x15=391
x20=358
x25=414
x30=364
x35=374
x40=428
x45=436
x50= 432
x60= 360
x70=412
x80=437
x90=415
x100=389
|
Smooth 223
Smooth 281
Smooth 318
Smooth 319
Smooth 319
Smooth 317
Smooth 331
Smooth 356
Smooth 364
Grooved 286
Smooth 215
Smooth 265
Smooth 317
Smooth 378
Grooved 263
|
x5=350
x10=360
x15=384
x20=392
x25=391
x30=391
x35=371
x40=389
x45=411
x50=397
x60=373
x70=431
x80=449
x90=457
x100=4531
|
Smooth 242
Smooth 289
Smooth 285
Smooth 331
Smooth 349
Smooth 362
Smooth 356
Smooth 337
Smooth 366
Grooved 280
Smooth 222
Smooth 328
Smooth 240
Smooth 381
Grooved 295
|
SWIBO Average
of the Tests #1 & #2
|
SWIBO 5.8404.16 →
|
Average
|
Steeling
|
|
Initial Sharpness
|
125
|
|
|
SHARPNESS
|
x5=355
x10=372
x15=388
x20=375
x25=403
x30=378
x35=373
x40=409
x45=424
x50=415
x60=367
x70=422
x80=443
x90=436
x100=410
|
Smooth 233
Smooth 285
Smooth 302
Smooth 325
Smooth 334
Smooth 340
Smooth 344
Smooth 347
Smooth 365
Grooved 283
Smooth 219
Smooth 297
Smooth 279
Smooth 380
Grooved 279
|
|
Average 1-50
|
389
|
smooth
319
|
|
Average 60-100
|
416
|
smooth
294
|
|
Average Smooth Steel
|
|
307
|
|
Average Grooved
|
|
281
|
|
Overall Average
|
402
|
294
|
|
GIESSER 2515 wwl 15 →
|
Test
#1
|
Steeling
|
Test
#2
|
Steeling
|
|
Initial Sharpness
|
151
|
|
157
|
|
|
SHARPNESS
|
x5=417
x10=426
x15=427
x20=392
x25=403
x30=414
x35=438
x40=431
x45=430
x50=456
x60=441
x70=451
x80=475
x90=489
x100=488
|
Smooth 355
Smooth 336
Smooth 332
Smooth 289
Smooth 367
Smooth 304
Smooth 358
Smooth 339
Smooth 379
Grooved 281
Smooth 271
Smooth 287
Smooth 309
Smooth 303
Grooved 201
|
x5=366
x10=425
x15=408
x20=399
x25=388
x30=402
x35=428
x40=426
x45=394
x50=425
x60=419
x70=427
x80=447
x90=426
x100=401
|
Smooth 281
Smooth 287
Smooth 258
Smooth 305
Smooth 354
Smooth 297
Smooth 352
Smooth 365
Smooth 342
Grooved 277
Smooth 197
Smooth 329
Smooth 395
Smooth 319
Grooved 262
|
GIESSER Average
of the Tests #1 & #2
|
GIESSER 2515 wwl 15 →
|
Average
|
Steeling
|
|
Initial Sharpness
|
154
|
|
|
SHARPNESS
|
x5=392
x10=426
x15=418
x20=396
x25=396
x30=408
x35=433
x40=429
x45=412
x50=441
x60=430
x70=439
x80=446
x90=458
x100=445
|
Smooth 318
Smooth 312
Smooth 295
Smooth 297
Smooth 361
Smooth 301
Smooth 355
Smooth 352
Smooth 361
Grooved 279
Smooth 234
Smooth 308
Smooth 352
Smooth 311
Grooved 232
|
|
Average 1-50
|
415
|
smooth
328
|
|
Average 60-100
|
444
|
Smooth
301
|
|
Average Smooth Steel
|
|
315
|
|
Average Grooved
|
|
256
|
|
Overall Average
|
430
|
285
|
|
VICTORINOX 5.6603.15 →
|
Test
#1
|
Steeling
|
Test
#2
|
Steeling
|
|
Initial Sharpness
|
150
|
|
136
|
|
|
SHARPNESS
|
x5=375
x10=444
x15=452
x20=474
x25=437
x30=446
x35=464
x40=482
x45=454
x50=463
x60=434
x70=439
x80=452
x90=426
x100=480
|
Smooth 348
Smooth 347
Smooth 385
Smooth 341
Smooth 361
Smooth 406
Smooth 408
Smooth 411
Smooth 450
Grooved 306
Smooth 228
Smooth 323
Smooth 299
Smooth 277
Grooved 229
|
x5=378
x10=405
x15=446
x20=375
x25=385
x30=431
x35=448
x40=475
x45=500
x50=468
x60=418
x70=483
x80=423
x90=447
x100=466
|
Smooth 332
Smooth 359
Smooth 389
Smooth 379
Smooth 332
Smooth 369
Smooth 337
Smooth 410
Smooth 418
Grooved 271
Smooth 261
Smooth 342
Smooth 286
Smooth 384
Grooved 250
|
VICTORINOX
Average of the Tests #1 & #2
|
VICTORINOX 5.6603.15 →
|
Average
|
Steeling
|
|
Initial Sharpness
|
143
|
|
|
SHARPNESS
|
x5=377
x10=425
x15=449
x20=425
x25=411
x30=439
x35=456
x40=479
x45=477
x50= 467
x60=426
x70=464
x80=438
x90=437
x100=473
|
Smooth 340
Smooth 353
Smooth 387
Smooth 360
Smooth 347
Smooth 388
Smooth 373
Smooth 411
Smooth 434
Grooved 289
Smooth 245
Smooth 333
Smooth 293
Smooth 331
Grooved 240
|
|
Average 1-50
|
441
|
smooth 377
|
|
Average 60-100
|
448
|
Smooth
301
|
|
Average Smooth Steel
|
|
339
|
|
Average Grooved
|
|
265
|
|
Overall Average
|
445
|
302
|
SWIBO HRC 57-58
|
Average 1-50
|
389
|
smooth
319
|
|
Average 60-100
|
416
|
smooth
294
|
|
Average Smooth Steel
|
|
307
|
|
Average Grooved
|
|
281
|
|
Overall Average
|
402
|
294
|
GEISSER HRC 56-57
|
Average 1-50
|
415
|
smooth
328
|
|
Average 60-100
|
444
|
Smooth
301
|
|
Average Smooth Steel
|
|
315
|
|
Average Grooved
|
|
256
|
|
Overall Average
|
430
|
285
|
VICTORINOX HRC 55-56
|
Average 1-50
|
441
|
smooth
377
|
|
Average 60-100
|
448
|
Smooth
301
|
|
Average Smooth Steel
|
|
339
|
|
Average Grooved
|
|
265
|
|
Overall Average
|
445
|
302
|
|